Truman Show

Customer reviews:

ONE WORD... STUPID, 2008-11-21
This is one stupid movie. Not just stupid, insultingly stupid. And the fact that there are so many glowing reviews proves how stupid human beings are in general. To make a long and very boring story short, the message is that we're not in control of our lives. We are mere puppets on a string... manipulated and controled by a higher power. Oh, and of course because movie makers and the media "think" they are Gods, why not portray themselves as such? So the whole movie is built around a bloody TV show! The producers etc are the "Gods" who can make anything happen... from the sun rising to the oceans storming. It's such a dumb premise I don't know where to begin. Allow me to ruin the movie by telling you the ending. Wait for it, wait for it... he sails to the end of the world (the ridiculously large "set") and walks off the show (walks out the exit door). Well done sir. It means absolutely nothing, but well done. So... what has changed for me after watching this movie? I still don't believe in a higher power. Never have, never will. I've always thought folks who live their lives through TV shows are pathetic (maybe the only positive message in this movie). And that's about it. All in all, a complete waste of time. I love movies with a powerful message. The Matrix worked for me on many levels, for example. The Matrix really peeled back the nature of our reality... creator vs. created, reality vs. social construct, good vs. evil, of course the obligatory love story, and so on. But THIS movie, was just plain pathetic. It also had that very insulting aspect to it. The insult being that those in the media, entertainment or otherwise, THINK they have so much power over "we the people" that they must use that power to warn us about it. Confused yet? It's not that complicated. I'll rephrase... the arrogant folks who made this movie, are SO full of themselves, that they believe TV, and by extension movies, have so much influence and control over us, that we are mere couch potatos. Sitting on the "sofa" of our lives, while TV tunes out the reality all around us. Now, maybe this is true for some (maybe it's true for many), but it's never been true for me, and I find it insulting. Thus my review. But am I giving this movie more credit than it deserves? Is it even that deep? Or am I reading meaning into a largely meaningless movie. Well... who cares? But if I'm right, take this movie's advice and don't waste your precious time watching it. Unplug your cable, cancel your NetFlix subsription, and go for a walk instead. Peace out.

The Reality of the Truman Show, 2008-11-06

The first time I saw The Truman Show, I was hooked. The movie is highly critical of the media and of how reality is manipulated to entertain the largest group of people. I have always been critical of the way television shows always claim to distribute "reality" to the public, and The Truman Show exemplifies many of the reasons reality television is so highly criticized. Truman, played by Jim Carrey, is an engaging character whose life is displayed on camera for the world to watch. He is surrounded by actors hired to interact with him and inspire the emotion that makes Truman so interesting to watch. The emotions and actions of the actors aren't real, so though they are believable, Truman's emotions and actions cannot be real either. Truman is floating in a naïve sense of truth. This movie illustrates how though we may believe that what the Television is flashing before us is reality, there is a truth much different from what is displayed on the screen; and we should be critical enough to see the real truth for ourselves.
Truman Burbank is the focus of a television show that began with his birth and subsequent adoption by the TV studio. Every aspect of his life is on camera, and there are thousands of cameras that follow every action from various vantage points. While he is growing up, going to school, and getting married, he is being watched. He is watched as he leaves his actor/wife to go to work in the morning, and watched as his actor/best friend hang out with a six-pack of beers. It all seems so quaint and real but the truth is that his life is a sham. His wife isn't real, she doesn't even like him, which he finds out by examining their wedding photos and finding that her fingers are crossed during their wedding kiss. His best friend Marlon isn't real; instead of being a true friend Marlon is used to manipulate Truman into certain frames of thought. He takes advantage of outings to hit some golf balls to convince Truman to stay put on his island instead of going to Fiji for a vacation.
Not only are the characters used to influence Truman's sense of reality, but the media in his world as well. The radio station creates a convenient explanation for the equipment which falls from the sky right as Truman is walking to his car in the morning. According to the announcer, a plane accidentally lost equipment that morning, causing the invasion into Truman's world. Truman's "father," who was killed off the show in a boating accident designed to make Truman terrified of the water, somehow manages to get back onto the set and disturb Truman's life. Seeing a man who is supposed to be dead alive once again is a big deal, and quite a shock, especially when random strangers appear out of nowhere and take the man away with no explanation at the time. The explanation comes from the newspaper which spins the incident into an issue of cleansing the town of homeless people and from the woman playing his mother, who claims that she "sees" Truman's father in every face on the street. Truman remains unconvinced, he knows what he saw for himself.
These events set off a chain reaction of discovery in Truman's life. He realizes that he is being followed when his radio accidentally picks up the frequency broadcasting the transmission from actor to actor. In an effort to discover some truth, Truman goes against his routine and visits the building next door to his, and sees people sitting at donut-laden tables where an elevator should be. After being dragged from the building he goes to see his wife, Meryl, at the hospital where she works. At every turn he is conveniently blocked by some obstacle or another and he cannot get into the operating room where she is performing "surgery." He attempts to fly to Fiji but is told by the travel agent that they are booked up for a month because it is the "busy season." When he tries to take a bus, the bus breaks down, and when he tries to drive away with Meryl, he runs into bumper to bumper traffic, a bridge over the water that terrifies him, a forest fire, and ultimately a nuclear meltdown which forces him to stop the car. When Truman tries to run, he is tackled by men in tinfoil suits and dragged back to his home.
All of these obstacles are the design of Christof, the creator, designer, and omnipotent watcher over Truman's life. He is responsible for every person Truman sees, every word they say to him, and every challenge he faces. He observes Truman from his studio in the moon and engineers heart-wrenching scenes with a frightening genius. The best example is probably the return of Truman's father, who is reunited with his son in a dramatic scene involving fog, various camera angles, and synthesized music all coming to a climax as Christof orchestrates the camera to a close-up as Truman embraces his father and sobs, "dad!" These are the scenes that drag the audiences into Truman's life, drawing on their sympathy and awe. They accept the reality as Christof presents it to them, drawn by the intrigue to watch more. Christof lets them see what he wants them to see, his story, and the audience blindly follows along. They either don't realize or choose not to see the reality of Truman's situation. His emotions and actions are being manipulated in the exact same way as theirs are.
It's too perfect, this scene and the entirety of the show Christof creates. When a caller on a talk show claims that Christof has turned Truman into something unreal, he replies, "I have given Truman the chance to lead a normal life. The world, the place you live in, is the sick place." I fail to see how his manipulations are any less sick than the terrible place he is protecting Truman from. His claim that he is "protecting" Truman reeks of protecting his interests as a TV show director and protecting the fan-base he has established with the show. He limits the information given to Truman and blocks his "star" from exploring the world outside his own, claiming that if Truman "was absolutely determined to discover the truth, there's no way we could prevent him." It seems that preventing Truman from discovering the truth is his sole goal. At the height of the film, Truman's life is a battle for the truth fought between him and the force he has found working against him, though he still doesn't know who he fights.
The stage for the final battle is set on the sea that separates Truman from the rest of the world. His desire for the truth is so strong he overcomes his terror of the water and attempts to sail to freedom. Christof sends him a storm complete with thunder and lightning and gale force winds. It is incredible that this storm is the result of two conflicting ideals, the seeker of truth and the keeper of the truth. This idea goes beyond mere reality TV and broadens to all media and even the government. It is easy to correlate the huge body of the government or the body of the media with Christof, the manipulator of the information and the figure who decides who hears and knows what. Truman is the people, the ignorant populace who is at first naïve and complacent but fierce in his desire for information once the ball is rolling.
Here is where the relationship between Truman and we the populace ends. We have not yet found that drive for knowledge, the real and true knowledge. We are just like the viewers of The Truman Show. We are still absorbed in the forged reality of the story and have not yet broken through the silver lining to the bare bones of what we are seeing. Truman should be our icon for reality and his drive should be our drive. Truman knows that the world outside his dome of illusion is different and new and unexpected. He may be afraid to step outside the door but what truly matters is the journey to get to the door and the realization that there is a door in the wall.